Will Fox’s ‘Glee’ be TV’s best new show? Don’t stop believing

Like  the motley misfits of Glee, I sometimes feel a bit slow. I missed the pilot’s premiere last May, not gleaning from the ads how good it was and figuring it’d be too much like High School Musical. (As if!)

But now, I have seen the light–and the pilot–twice, in fact, the week before Glee’s full-season premiere. And am I on board with Glee? Is Les Miz not a great source for audition numbers? These are rhetorical questions, so let’s move on.

You should know: I’m a veteran entertainment writer (spent many years at papers in Houston, Okla. City, Austin, Fort Worth, etc.) and have seen it all. That doesn’t mean I’m jaded. It means I know the difference between the truly great, the numbing mass of middle-ground mediocrity, and the truly awul.

Glee is truly great. I mean, it’s been ages since a new TV series was so right and so good in so many ways.

Obviously the first big way is the music, for which Glee provided so much in its pilot — even down to the anything-but-incidental background songs. (All those rights! I tell ya, Fox is spending some money.) But the soaring, inspiring, show-ending performance of Don’t Stop Believing — well, it just doesn’t get any better. If that song doesn’t sell ya, nothing will.

I often bemoan “If I ran Hollywood,” then specify exactly how I’d do it. For one thing, if you truly want to be creative and original and really go for it with something fresh and new and distinctive, cast fresh faces. Don’t lean on name actors first discovered by other people — well, hire some. But find new names yourself, and make them stars.

Ryan Murphy, Glee’s co-producer-writer-director, has done this. He’s assembled a cast from head-shot and audition heaven. And though it’s a great ensemble, the breakout for me is Lea Michele, a young woman who — can’t help it — reminds me a bit of Rent’s Idina Menzel (this is the last time I’m mentioning it!) but is her own powerhouse performer.

Ms. Michele (my wife of the same name appreciates the proper French spelling) also seems just as born  and driven and hungry to do musical theater as is  her character, Rachel, the gleeks’ best girl singer. Scrub that. Best singer.

Also new — to me — is Matthew Morrison as the club’s nice-guy coach and put-upon teacher. And then there’s the rest of the gleeks. Love them! Kevin McHale? I thought he was GM of the Minnesota T Wolves. Nope, the actor who pretends to need a wheelchair is a bright new talent — with amazing discipline not to move his legs while castmates dance up a storm around him.

Jane Lynch? The Chris Guest trouper (and 2 1/2 Men, Boston Legal, etc. guest star)  has always been fun. Here, as the show’s haughty power-mad cheerleader-coach foil for the underdog gleeks, she’s got a great role to sink her comic teeth into and not let go —  at least for 13 episodes, though surely Glee will be renewed for mid-season.

Those are reasons enough to watch Wednesdays at 8 (that’s CST — I’m in Houston). But for this show, what really POPS — what really shines beyond the great music and the great cast — is something very special, very unusual, even for today’s most-watched shows.

It’s something that starts on the page and extends through casting, direction and performances. Quite simply, it’s characters you can REALLY CARE ABOUT — not because the script, the setup, the billing or the hype tell you to, but because they’ve earned it.

I care about these folks — lots of ’em — and on what other show is that true? On Ugly Betty, I’m impressed by Wilhelmina and amused by Mark, but only care about  Betty, while  exasperated by her. On Desperate Housewives, I can respect the dark humor and shrewd scheming, but who’s to like?

On Glee, I not only love the core gleeks — love ’em —  but even understand their nemeses. As Murphy spins it, everybody’s human, which is the kind of tolerance our Glee heroes only wish were a mantra. And everybody has a selfish, dark side — or at least sliver. But here, only a few really pursue life from their hearts, not from avarice, bitchy insistence on conformity or projection of lousy status standards.

As I say, I’m on board. And you are welcome to join me here. This will not be a shrieking hot tamale train of mindless hype. It will be a non-loco locomotive that tells it like it is (if I carp, it’s cuz I love), cherishes musical expression more than any art and values true show-biz inspiration.

We don’t see that a lot, but we’re seeing it now. We’re seeing it in Glee.

All aboard.


9 Responses to “Will Fox’s ‘Glee’ be TV’s best new show? Don’t stop believing”

  1. pegasusunder Says:

    You hit it right on the nail…I really can’t say how much i LOVED this show. It is different, and brilliantly so. I will be watching!

  2. ellis Says:

    I’m positively glee-ful.

  3. ‘Glee’ blog: ‘Glee’ pushes it with fun fall premiere « Tripping the Light Says:

    […] Tripping the Light Just another WordPress.com weblog « Will Fox’s ‘Glee’ be TV’s best new show? Don’t stop believing […]

  4. ‘Glee’ pilot, preview, T-shirt for $5? I’ll buy that « Tripping the Light Says:

    […] WordPress.com weblog « ‘Adventureland’ on DVD could be more adventurous Will Fox’s ‘Glee’ be TV’s best new show? Don’t stop believing […]

  5. Glee Blog Episode 3–Acafellas: Nerdlets need confidence « Tripping the Light Says:

    […] spoiled me — already. I expect each episode to end with a stirring (Take a Bow) or rousing (Don’t Stop Believin’) show-stopper of fervent, belting beauty — and  Acafellas did not have […]

  6. Glee Episode 5 The Rhodes Not Taken: Music, music, music « Tripping the Light Says:

    […] there you have it. Glee is clearly capable of hitting its pilot episode stride yet again, and may even do so another time next week, when girls-vs.-boys mashups will burst […]

  7. Watch Glee Online Free Says:

    After watching the pilot I wasn’t sure about Glee, but as I watched each episode I got into it more and more.

  8. Watch Glee Free Says:

    Hey , really nice write up . Keep up the good work.

  9. Robert Lautaret Says:

    I really love this show.. I have watched all episodes and I can’t wait for the next one…!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: