As a longtime admirer of the reliable and prolific Stephen King, I cut him some slack.
I don’t mind – much – when he indulges himself with steady streams of literary references in his tale-telling – references to various writers and titles, which may befit King more than the characters. (Well, they do say to write what you know.) And I don’t mind when he cuts back and forth through time rather than write a linear plot with logical through lines, especially when such intercuts artfully stitch together flashbacks and the tale’s current time.
Such is the case for his latest novel, “Holly” (from Scribner), which boldly reveals the “who” of its whodunit in the opening pages, then entwines years of ongoing kidnappings and murders with a current-time investigation of the latest crime by the heroine of its title: Holly Gibney.
Introduced as a mousy wallflower in the riveting trilogy starting with “Mr. Mercedes,” she flowers here into an intrepid lead character with her own tiny private-eye agency.
Was I impatient for spunky Holly to pierce the mystery of dawning coincidences which became much more, then zero-in on the horrid predators who’d been getting away with ghastly crimes?
Not really. The joy is in the journey, as they say, and King’s vividly descriptive prose and way with spinning a compelling yarn makes “Holly” a solid, absorbing read despite knowing the “who” in advance of Holly’s methodical sleuthing.
But what really sells me on this relatively brief, for King, novel of 446 pages is what I like to call, in rock ‘n’ roll terms, the Big Finishing Kick.
“Holly” has one.
Does it ever.
For a rock comparison, a younger Bruce Springsteen once stretched out three-minute songs to 10 minutes or more by building toward a sustained ending with furious energy that kept the song going, and going, and going. Or take the last couple of minutes of Meat Loaf’s “I’m Gonna Love Her for Both of Us,” rife with utter abandon.
Though a novel, not a song, “Holly” has that kind of ending. It sweeps you up and swoops you along with its edgy, relentless power.
The book hits that galvanizing rush to the finish about 60 pages from the end, when things get confrontational in a grandly grisly high gear. Some would call that a “page turner,” but the term doesn’t do it justice. You want to read on so quickly to reach the denouement that it’s more of a “page burner” in your hands.
Mr. King, I salute you.
As for the setup, I won’t bestow much here, since as a reviewer I avoid too much regurgitation of details when the reader should enjoy his or her own discoveries. But I will say this:
As revealed at the start, the crimes involve two unlikely culprits: aging, retired members of a nearby college’s faculty, who touchingly dote on and love each other but, to ward off age’s ravages – and heed the husband’s wacky theories about human flesh being rejuvenating – have resorted to carefully planned schemes of snatching folks they dislike and – there’s no point soft-pedaling this – devouring them.
Oh, yes. You’ll be sorry you peeked into the Harris couple’s basement – and their fridge. As King fans know, non-supernatural yarns in his hands can be just as disturbing as those with fangs or fiery powers.
From her fledgling detective agency, Holly is set on the case by the frantic mother of their latest victim. It seems 20-something daughter Bonnie has gone missing with no apparent signs of foul play.
I know, I know: “I want my kid back” is one of the basic plots of Writing 101, along with “save the farm,” “find the thing,” “get revenge” and “boy meets girl.” But as Holly soon learns, there’s more than one missing person connected with this latest supposed runaway or feared victim.
Piecing the puzzle together is a low-key delight, interspersed with then and now flashes to the crazed couple and their dietary devilry. Then it’s time to brace yourself for the furious finish.
Along the way, King does what you’d expect, given his outspoken social media commentaries and the fact that this tale occurs during the height of the COVID pandemic: He rips the holy hell out of politicized deniers of the “fake flu” who cling to nutty conspiracy theories and look pityingly at Holly with her protective mask and offer of an elbow instead of shaking hands.
King also delves into Holly’s psychological issues, most of which concern her late mother, whose rent-free presence in her tormented mind makes Mom not quite dead, not when scathing memories remain — and a freshly unearthed cruelty arises.
Any way you slice it, there’s more to this tale than cannibalism and a trailblazing female detective (in a way, a modern cousin of the heroine of PBS’s “Miss Scarlet and the Duke”). Also meaty are Holly’s inner battles while the outer world staggers from soaring COVID deaths and willful ignorance.
When King is done with all that–and with us, his faithful readers– you just might be exhausted from your rapid reading and frantic page turning. But that’s a good thing.
Like fans at the end of a mammoth Springsteen show, you’re drained, but also elated. You have experienced the Big Finishing Kick, literary style. And only the ungrateful would expect or demand more.
–Bruce Westbrook